Share / Export Citation / Email / Print / Text size:

Transport Problems

Silesian University of Technology

Subject: Economics, Transportation, Transportation Science & Technology


eISSN: 2300-861X



VOLUME 12 , ISSUE 4 (December 2017) > List of articles



Keywords : freight mode choice, road and rail, logistics system

Citation Information : Transport Problems. Volume 12, Issue 4, Pages 37-50, DOI:

License : (CC BY 4.0)

Received Date : 11-July-2016 / Accepted: 06-December-2017 / Published Online: 03-March-2018



This research analyses the competitive advantages of road and rail transport through the example of Ukraine transportation market. Spheres of efficient usage of rail and road transport while transporting perishable goods have been studied. The key factors influencing the mode choice, as well as the kinds of cargo that depend on the mode choice have been determined with the help of revealed preference data. A mathematical model of mode choice has been offered. The criterion of the effectiveness of this model is the economical profit of the logistics system ‘shipper – carrier – receiver’. The advantage of using the suggested model is the possibility of calculating invisible costs while evaluating alternative transport mode, including funds immobilization and cargo loss. The tools in the study are the methods of system analysis, mathematical modelling, regression analysis and expert evaluations. The acquired results can be used while justifying the mode choice and determining the spheres of efficient usage of various modes of transport. It has been determined that the factor for using the rail is the distance longer than 600 km, as the economical profit of the logistics system is higher in this case. At the same time, with distances shorter than 600 km, road transportation is a better choice.

Content not available PDF Share



Транспорт і зв’язок України. Статистичний збірник. Київ: Державна служба статистики країни. 2015. 204 с. Available at: [In Ukrainian: Transport and communications of Ukraine. Statistical yearbook. State statistics servise of Ukraine].


Транспортна стратегія України на період до 2020 року. Розпорядження Кабінету Міністрів України від 20 жовтня 2010 р. No. 2174. Available at: 2174-2010-%D1%80 [In Ukrainian: The Transport Strategy of Ukraine up to 2020. The Resolution of the Government of Ukraine]


Crisalli, U. & Comi, A. & Rosati, L. A methodology for the assessment of rail-road freight transport policies. In: Sidt Scientific Seminar 2012. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences. 2013. Vol. 87. P. 292-305.


Gursoy, M. A method for transportation mode choice. Scientific Research and Essays. 2010. Vol. 5(7). P. 613-624.


Wang, Y.W. & Ding, C. & Liu, C. & Xie, B.L. An analysis of Interstate freight mode choice between truck and rail: A case study of Maryland, United States. Intelligent and Integrated Sustainable Multimodal Transportation Systems. In: The 13th Cota International Conference of Transportation Professionals. Procedia – Social and Behavioral Sciences. 2013. Vol. 96. P. 1239-1249.


Danielis, R. & Rotaris, L. Analysing freight transport demand using stated preference data. European Transport / Trasporti Europei. Vol. 13. P. 30-38.


Meixell, M.J. & Norbis, M. A review of the transportation mode choice and carrier selection literature. International Journal of Logistics Management. 2008. Vol. 19(2). Р. 183-211.


Van Jaarsveld, L. & Heyns, G.J & Kilbourn, P.J. Logistics opportunity costs: A mining case study. Journal of Transport and Supply Chain Management. 2013. Vol. 7(1). P. 1-11.


Kim, H.C. Developing a Mode Choice Model for New Zealand Freight Transportation. Thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy in Civil Engineering.


Arencibia, A.I. & Feo-Valero, M. & Garcia-Menendez, L. & Roman, C. Modelling mode choice for freight transport using advanced choice experiments. Transportation Research Part a-Policy and Practice. 2015. Vol. 75. P. 252-267.

 Moschovou, T.P. & Giannopoulos, G.A. Modeling Freight Mode Choice in Greece. Transport Research Arena. 2012. Vol. 48. P. 597-611.


Shin, S. & Park, D. & Shon, E. & Choi, C. et al. Development of freight mode choice model using sp data. Transportation Systems: Engineering & Management. 2007. P. 363-371.


Picard, G. & Gaudry, M. Exploration of a Box Cox logit model of intercity freight mode choice. Transportation Research P.E -Logistics and Transportation Review. 1998. Vol. 34(1). P. 1-12.


Цветов, Ю.М. Теоретические и практические основы организации управления разными видами транспорта и их взаимодействия при перевозке грузов. Dr. Econ. Sciences. Арендный институт комплексных транспортных проблем. 1993. 53 с. [In Russian: Tsvetov, Y.M. Theoretical and practical principles of organization of management of different types of transport and their interaction in the transport of goods: the author's abstract. Dr. Econ. Sciences. Rent Institute of Complex Transport Problems]


Правдин, Н.В. & Негрей, В.А. Взаимодействие различных видов транспорта в узлах. 2-е изд. перераб. и доп. Мн: Выш. Школа, 1983. 247с. [In Russian: Pravdin, N.V. & Negrei, V.A. Interaction of different transport mode in the nodes. Minsk: High Shcool]


Arnold, P. & Peeters, D. & Thomas, I. Modeling a rail/road intermodal transportation system. Transportation Research Part E: Logistics and Transportation Review. 2004. Vol. 40 (3). P. 255-270.


Ballis, A. & Golias, J. Comparative evaluation of existing and innovative rail–road freight transport terminals. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice. 2002. Vol. 36 (7). P. 593-611.


Janic, M. Modelling the full costs of an intermodal and road freight transport network. Transportation Research Part D: Transport and Environment. 2007. Vol. 12 (1). P. 33-44.


Дмитриев, В. И. Сопоставление издержек разных видов транспорта. М.: Транспорт, 1972. 486 с. [In Russian: Dmitriev, V.I. Comparison of the costs of different types of transport. Moscow: Transport].


Kim, D. & Shon, E. & Park, D. & Choi, C. & et al. Influential attributes in freight mode choice decisions: focusing on container, cement and steel manufacturers. Transportation Systems: Engineering & Management. 2007. P. 585-592.


Derakhshan, A. & Zaly Shah, M. Analysis of Inland Mode Choice Decision for Imported Waterborne Cargo from New York & New Jersey Ports. European Transport. 2013. Issue XX. Vol. 55. P. 1-19.


Saeed, N. Cooperation among freight forwarders: Mode choice and intermodal freight transport. Research in Transportation Economics. 2013. Vol. 42. P. 77-86.


Тихончук, Ю.Н. & Елисеева, Т.В. & Каяшев, А.В. Рациональное распределение перевозок между железнодорожным и автомобильным транспортом. – М.: Транспорт, 1972. 136 с. [In Russian: Tikhonchuk, Yu. N. & Eliseeva, T.V. & Kayashev, A.V. Rational transportation distribution between road and rail transport. Moscow: Transport].


Reis, V. Analysis of mode choice variables in short-distance intermodal freight transport using an agent-based model. Transportation Research P. A - Policy and Practice. 2014. Vol. 61. Р. 100-120.


Mathisen, T.A. &. Hanssen, T.E.S. & Jorgensen, F. & Larsen, B. Ranking of transport modes - Intersections between price curves for transport by truck, rail, and water. European Transport-Trasporti Europei. 2015. Vol. 57. P. 1-14.


Wang, M. & Soc, I. C. Uncertain Analysis of Inventory Theoretic Model for Freight Mode Choice. In: International Conference on Intelligent Computation Technology and Automation. Proceedings. 2008. Vol 2. P. 579-583.


Dullaert, W. & Vernimmen, B. & Aghezzaf, E. & Raa, B. Revisiting service-level measurement for an inventory system with different transport modes. Transport Reviews. 2007. Vol. 27(3). P. 273-283.


Norojono, O. & Young W. A stated preference freight mode choice model. Transportation Planning and Technology. 2003. Vol. 26(2). P. 195-212.


Пономарьова, Н.В. Прогнозування вантажопотоків на наземних видах транспорту у міжнародному сполученні. PhD thesis. Харків: ХНАДУ. 2007. 20 с. [In Russian: Ponomarova, N.V. Prediction of freight on land transport in international traffic: the author's abstract. PhD thesis. Kharkiv: Khnade].


Выбор вариантов доставки грузов на основе равновыгодных расстояний с учетом иммобилизации средств. Инновации бизнесу. Avaiable at: http://www.ideasandmoney .ru/Ntrr/Details/147585 [In Russian: Choosing options for delivery of goods on the basis of equivalent distances based immobilization of funds. Innovation for business]


Zhao, X. & Yang, Z. & Yang, Z. Z. & Feng, Y. Study on the choice of transportation mode for regional logistics. In: 6th Conference of the Eastern-Asia-Society-for-Transportation-Studies. Bangkok, Thailand: Eastern Asia Soc Transportat Studies. 2005. Vol. 5. P. 16-31.


A latent class model with attribute cut-offs to analyze modal choice for freight transport. Avaiable at:


Haugen, K.K. & Hervik A. A game theoretic "mode-choice" model for freight transportation. Annals of Regional Science. 2004. Vol. 38(3). P. 469-484.


Samimi, A. & Mohammadian, A. & Kawamura, K. & Pourabdollahi, Z. An activity-based freight mode choice microsimulation model. Transportation Letters-the International Journal of Transportation Research. 2014. Vol. 6(3). P. 142-151.


Ribbink, D. & Van Riel, A.C.R. & Semeijn, J. Policy decisions and modal choice: An example from the European Union. Transportation Journal. 2005. Vol. 44(1). P. 33-44.


Rowangould, G. Public financing of private freight rail infrastructure to reduce highway congestion: A case study of public policy and decision making in the United States. Transportation Research Part a-Policy and Practice. 2013. Vol. 57. P. 25-36.


Freight. Department for transport. Avaiable at:


Shyrіaieva, S.V. & Konrad, T.I. Analysis of the current state of road and rail transportation of perishable goods in Ukraine. Visnyk National Transport University. Kyiv. National Transport University. 2013. Vol. 28.


Осипов, Я.И. Оценка стоимости компании с помощью экономической и бухгалтерской прибыли. Российское предпринимательство. 2011. Avaiable at: /articles/11729/ [In Russian: Choosing options for delivery of goods on the basis of equivalent distances based immobilization of fund. Russian entrepreneur]


Рославцев, Д.Н. Оценка эффективности решений в проектах модернизации логистических цепей. Восточно-Европейский журнал передовых технологий. 2010. Vol. 5/3(47). P. 18–20. [In Russian: Roslavtsev, D.N. Evaluating the effectiveness of solutions in the projects of modernization of supply chains. Eastern-European Journal of Eenterprise Technologies].


Galkin A. Urban environment influence on distribution part of logistics systems. Archives of Transport. 2017. Vol. 42(2). P. 7-23.


Самойленко, М.І. Математичне програмування: навч. посіб. – Харків: Основа, 2002. 424 с. [In Ukrainian: Samoilenko, M.I. Mathematical programming. Kharkiv. Osnova].


Ольхова, М.В. Дослідження закономірностей зміни обсягу магістральних вантажних перевезень. Восточно-Европейский журнал передовых технологий. 2012. No. 3/11(57). С. 70-72. [In Ukrainian: Olkhova, M.V. Research of laws of cargo amount while trunk transportation. Eastern-European Journal of Eenterprise Technologies].


Воркут, А.И. Грузовые автомобильные перевозки. Киев: Вища школа. Головное изд-во. 1986. 447 р. [In Russian: Vorkut, A. I. Freight transportation by road. Kiev: High School. The Main Publishing House].